What's riskier for young soccer players, practice or game time?
For young soccer players, participating in repetitive technical training activities involving heading during practice may result in more total head impacts – but playing in scrimmages or actual soccer games may result in greater magnitude head impacts. That's according to a small, preliminary study released recently at the American Academy of Neurology's Sports Concussion Conference.
"Headers are a fundamental component to the sport of soccer, therefore it is important to understand differences in header frequency and magnitude across practice and game settings," said Dr. Jillian Urban of the Wake Forest School of Medicine in Winston-Salem, N.C., and the study’s author. "Practices are more amenable to change than games. Therefore, understanding how we can restructure practice to reduce head impact exposure while teaching fundamental skills needed to safely play the sport is critical to improving head impact safety in the sport."
The study followed eight soccer players who were ages 14 and 15 for two seasons. Players wore a custom-fitted mouthpiece sensor during all practices and games. Researchers recorded all activities on the field with a time-synchronized camera, and identified each time head contact was made.
Head impact exposure was quantified in terms of peak head motion and impacts per player per hour, or impact rate. The amount of time an athlete was exposed to an activity was also evaluated. Researchers then compared impact rates across activity types which ranged from 0.5 head impacts per player hour to 13.7 head impacts per player hour.
Researchers saw a similar number of player-to-player contacts happening during technical drills, team interaction and game play. Technical training activities like heading the ball and practicing ball-control and dribbling were associated with an average impact rate of 13.7 head impacts per player hour. Team interaction activities such as small-sided games in practice were associated with an average impact rate of 0.5 head impacts per player per hour, which was slightly lower than the 1.3 head impacts per player hour observed during games.
"If the goal is to reduce the number of head impacts a young soccer player may get on the field, our findings suggest the best way may be to target technical training drills and how they are distributed within a season," said Urban. "However, if the goal is to reduce the likelihood of players sustaining head impacts of greater magnitude, then the best bet may be to look at factors associated with high-magnitude head impacts that can occur during scrimmages and games."
A limitation of the study is the small number of players involved.
The study was supported in part by the Childress Institute for Pediatric Trauma.
Coaches displaying authentic leadership qualities can help athletes find more enjoyment in competing, and stay involved in sports longer, according to new study
Leading active lives as youth may protect against dementia in older years
However, kids who exclusively play individual sports more likely to face mental health challenges, researchers report
Study finds more fruits and veggies means less inattention